Have a tendency to whenever schedules are provided, he’s given having a day of day you to does not meets with that day as it from inside the actual history. One such example occurs in Harry Potter and also the Prisoner out-of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to sixteen October just like the Monday, even though 16 Oct 1993 are a monday.
There are even contradictions in books in this region. For example, when you look at the Harry Potter additionally the Cup regarding Flame, both step one September and you will dos Sep are offered because the Mondays and, from inside the Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined to the 20 April, but careful parsing of your text suggests that this may have happened no after than simply March.
Along with, from inside the Harry Potter and also the Goblet from Flame they claim the Champions was in fact chose toward Saturday 29 October, but 31 October are a tuesday when you look at the 1994.
Inside the a bankruptcy proceeding off Quidditch From Age, they do say that very first Quidditch Globe Glass occured in 1473. If for example the title is actually held most of the several years, that it disputes on declaration within the Goblet away from Flame that 1994 Industry Glass is actually the newest 422nd. In the event the Quidditch From Ages is good, the latest 422nd Quidditch Community Mug perform actually fall-in the year 3161, in case Cup away from Fire is useful, the first Business Glass was held for the 306.
Historic problems [ ]
Even though the series, with respect to the timeline produced from the fresh Chamber out-of Secrets source, is decided from the 1990s, the newest collection commonly appears as if it’s invest the later nineties to mid-2000s, about concurrent on publication of courses. Inside Harry Potter and 50 % of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to refer for the “predecessor” of your Best Minister of your British. With regards to the a lot more than timeline, this should occur in summer time off 1996, if the Primary Minister are John Significant, whoever instant ancestor try a lady (‘s the reason first interviewing Fudge, the publication states new election, but Major was not initially picked and simply got over just after Thatcher retired.
It’s possible, not unrealistic, one Fudge would-be speaing frankly about a more faraway predecessor, as Thatcher got place of work in advance of Fudge allegedly turned into Minister to have Wonders. (Whether or not one could thought a scenario where Fudge are delegated by Minister getting Magic to meet up with into the Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller office.) Concurrently, the brand new identity and you will reputation of the top Minister portrayed seems to far more directly suits compared to Tony Blair than away from John Significant. A blog post on Every day Mail cards one to Rowling is actually close on the then-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brown (usually considered a competitor to Blair’s leaders of one’s Labour People, which been successful your and you can turned Primary Minister), and therefore she has been attempting to let you know Blair’s poor front side. In case the courses was set in connect which have guide big date out-of Philosopher’s Stone, after that this event do take place in 2002 (once Blair became Primary Minister).
Although not, it was afterwards stated that twenty two November is a monday, that it was at 1994
An equivalent problem concerns Nicolas Flamel, who was simply mentioned as being 665 in the course of the brand new earliest book, however, Nicolas Flamel are a real historic profile and you may won’t reach that years up until 1996, around the day the first guide was wrote. The newest rebuttal for it is the fact that the day the “real” Nicolas Flamel came to be will not correspond with the new Nicolas Flamel of Harry Potter.
An alternate disease is obtainable out-of Rubeus Hagrid’s period because the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s created throughout the show one Hagrid received you to status within this many years regarding his expulsion away from school in 1942. But in you to scene off Harry Potter and the Cup out-of Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper frequently convergence which have Molly’s many years at school, it looks impractical you to definitely she remembers a past gamekeeper. not, you will be able you to Hagrid didn’t end up being a great gamekeeper instantly once being expelled, but alternatively started while the Ogg’s secretary. It is possible just like the whenever Harry believes that he will be expelled to possess flying toward broomstick versus permission within his first 12 months, he magic if he’d be allowed to stick to as Hagrid’s assistant.